PSYCHOLOGY

The Problem With Jane Elliott’s “One Race” Theory

The good, the bad, and the ugly about the Blue Eyes/Brown Eyes experiment and its creator

Dr. Allison Wiltz
Momentum
Published in
6 min readMar 16, 2024

--

Jane Elliott at Riceville, Iowa, Elementary School in 1968 | Photo taken by Charlotte Button

Jane Elliott, an educator, school teacher, and diversity consultant, has become well-known for her anti-racism work. Her claim to scholarly fame was her Blue Eyes/Brown Eyes experiment, which she conducted for the first time in an all-white Ohio classroom on April 5, 1968, one day after Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated. As a diversity consultant, Elliott has repeated his exercise numerous times. Companies like General Electric, Exxon, AT&T, and IBM hired her for training sessions. Even the Department of Education and Postal Service retained Elliott for diversity training. To understand the impact of her work and a key flaw in her “one race” theory, we should review her infamous study.

First, Elliott divided the classroom into two groups, one reserved for students with blue eyes and the other with brown eyes. Then, she told the class that blue-eyed children were superior and provided them extra privileges, like skipping to the front of the lunch line, receiving extra portions, and having more play time and attention from the teacher. She encouraged them to play only with other blue-eyed students and ignore brown-eyed students, who…

--

--

Momentum
Momentum

Published in Momentum

Momentum is a blog that captures and reflects the moment we find ourselves in, one where rampant anti-Black racism is leading to violence, trauma, protest, reflection, sorrow, and more. Momentum doesn’t look away when the news cycle shifts.

Dr. Allison Wiltz
Dr. Allison Wiltz

Written by Dr. Allison Wiltz

Black womanist scholar with a PhD from New Orleans, LA with bylines in Oprah Daily, Momentum, ZORA, Cultured. #WEOC Founder

Responses (37)