RACISM

Why Portraying a Black Victim as The Suspect is Media Malpractice

This case of mistaken identity has racial connotations

Allison Wiltz M.S.
Momentum
Published in
5 min readSep 6, 2024

--

Black student doing his homework | Photo by Katerina Holmes

To err is human,” the English poet Alexander Pope suggested in his 1711 Essay on Criticism. And yet, some errors are more egregious than others. For instance, after a shooting at Apalachee High School in Georgia, WSB-TV, an Atlanta station, made a faux pas that reignited the national conversation about racial bias in media reporting. The outlet posted a link to a new article using a photo of Mason Schermerhorn, a 14-year-old Black victim of the shooting with the caption “suspect, Colt Gray, was arrested.” The Daily Mail made the same misstep, misidentifying the Black student killed in the attack with the alleged shooter. Spilling a glass of milk is not the same as portraying a homicide victim as the perpetrator. While the former only requires a mop to clean, the other has a messier consequence. Sadly, even though Mason became a victim of gun violence, many Americans saw his face for the first time, portrayed as the suspect of a horrendous crime, a school shooting he was a victim of.

Two students and two teachers were killed in the Georgia school shooting, and nine more suffered injuries. And yet, the irony isn’t lost on the black community that the only victim whose image was…

--

--

Allison Wiltz M.S.
Momentum

Black womanist scholar and doctoral candidate from New Orleans, LA with bylines @ Momentum, Oprah Daily, ZORA, Cultured #WEOC Founder. allisonthedailywriter.com